B.R.A.D. experts push back on Belton Court housing development plan

Experts offer testimony to Barrington Planning Board

By Josh Bickford
Posted 5/5/26

Wade Palazini seemed to speak a special, unique language, using terms like “short-jacking apparatus” and “NFPA” and “flow tests.”

A principal at Jensen Hughes in Lincoln, Palazini …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Register to post events


If you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here.

Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content.

Day pass subscribers

Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.


B.R.A.D. experts push back on Belton Court housing development plan

Experts offer testimony to Barrington Planning Board

Posted

Wade Palazini seemed to speak a special, unique language, using terms like “short-jacking apparatus” and “NFPA” and “flow tests.”

A principal at Jensen Hughes in Lincoln, Palazini serves as a senior fire building code consultant, and on Tuesday night, April 28, he provided testimony to the Barrington Planning Board about the proposed Belton Court Village housing project. 

Palazini offered details involving “gallons per minute” and road widths, and repeatedly told members of the board that the developer’s application was missing key information, data that the town’s fire chief needed before he could be expected to make any determination on whether the proposed housing development complies with fire codes. 

Palazini was one of the half-dozen people who spoke on behalf of the residents’ group B.R.A.D. on April 28. The experts discussed a range of topics, each focused on the proposed development — the affordable housing component of the project,  the environmental impacts, traffic studies, the future of Belton Court mansion, fire codes and other regulations. The testimony served as a counter to the development team’s presentation at earlier planning board meetings. 

B.R.A.D. — Barrington Residents for Appropriate Development — also submitted a voluminous binder of information to the planning board, a response to the application from property owner Shineharmony Holdings, LLC, which is proposing a 344-unit housing development on the former Zion Bible College campus. 

Melissa Horne, an attorney with Higgins, Cavanagh and Cooney, is representing B.R.A.D. She said the planning board should deny the developer’s application. Horne said Shineharmony Holdings officials did not give much thought to the impacts their development would have on health and safety concerns, stormwater runoff, the naturally high water table in that part of town, and whether the project could provide enough water to fight a fire without affecting the surrounding neighborhoods. She and other presenters offered dozens of questions and concerns that they believe should be considered by planning board members as they decide on the permit application. 

Horne, standing at a microphone near the Barrington Middle School stage, focused some of her presentation on affordable housing — she said Shineharmony’s proposal may include some units of affordable housing but it fails to offer the type of affordable housing that is specifically required in the town’s comprehensive plan. She said the town’s plan calls for affordable housing for adults with physical and developmental needs, and age-restricted senior affordable housing. 

Horne said the developer is trying to take advantage of the density allowed in the property’s zoning, and also double-dip with the affordable housing density bonus. But, Horne added, the property’s zoning calls for a continuing care, age-restricted development. That is not what Shineharmony has planned, she said. 

Horne said the plan for Belton Court Village is “not consistent with local needs…”

Groundwater expert

Scott Horsly, an independent consulting hydrologist who has worked with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and served as an expert witness in state and federal courts, spoke about groundwater, runoff and the water table. 

Horsly, who teaches at Harvard and Tufts, detailed a series of concerns with the development’s impact on groundwater and flooding issues. He said two changes associated with the project will affect groundwater levels and water flow in that part of Barrington. He said the first change is the reduced vegetation on the site as a result of the proposed construction. The second is the increased amount of impervious surfaces. 

Horsly said those changes will increase the water recharge rate and the water table will rise. He said 14% of the site is currently covered in impervious material — asphalt, concrete, buildings, etc. That figure will jump to 42% — three times as much — after development, he said. Horsly said the impervious areas now cover 4.4 acres, but would increase to 13.1 acres. 

Horsly also raised concerns with the developer’s plan to use bioswales as a water runoff reduction tool. He said he ran an analysis that shows the water table would increase and flood the infiltration basins. Just a one-foot rise in groundwater, he said, would leave those systems sitting in water. 

Belton Court

B.R.A.D. also offered testimony from Steve Mar-Pohl, the president of Insight Consulting Architects. Mar-Pohl focused on Belton Court mansion — the former Peck family estate that is included on the National Register of Historic Places. The developer’s plan calls for Belton Court to be demolished; only the tower and the stables are part of future plans. 

Mar-Pohl told the planning board that he is a lover of historic buildings and has studied them around the world. He said he has seen many historic buildings that have been neglected and allowed to fall into disrepair. Mar-Pohl said the “bones” of those structures, like those of Belton Court mansion, are very solid. He said that makes restoration possible and affordable. Mar-Pohl also said the development plan could easily be altered to include restoration of the historic estate. 

Mar-Pohl challenged Shineharmony’s plan to preserve only a portion of the building. He said retention of isolated elements is not preservation, and that removing parts of the building could undermine the structural integrity of the remaining building. 

Mar-Pohl said that demolition of Belton Court, which he estimated to cost between $3 to $5 million, would be a waste of valuable resources. He also said the damage to Belton Court was a shame, but it actually provided flexibility to a restoration effort. He also said restoration costs can compete with new construction costs. 

Other presenters at the April 28 meeting included Carla DeStefano, who focused on the affordable housing component of the application. She said the developer should be including more units at a lower cost — the plan currently includes all 86 affordable units to be priced at 120% of the area median income. Shana Gare, a project manager with Bowman Engineering, provided testimony on the traffic impacts. 

2026 by East Bay Media Group

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.