Portsmouth’s past comes alive

Gloria Schmidt’s new book uncovers the colorful characters, forgotten scandals and even a famous cow that helped shape Portsmouth

By Jim McGaw
Posted 11/18/26

PORTSMOUTH — Whatever you do, don’t call Gloria Schmidt a historian.

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Register to post events


If you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here.

Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content.

Day pass subscribers

Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.


Portsmouth’s past comes alive

Gloria Schmidt’s new book uncovers the colorful characters, forgotten scandals and even a famous cow that helped shape Portsmouth

Posted

PORTSMOUTH — Whatever you do, don’t call Gloria Schmidt a historian.

“Sometimes people label me as a historian, and that doesn’t sit well with me. I think of myself more as a storykeeper,” she told a large gathering at the Portsmouth Free Public Library on Monday evening, Nov. 9.

Of course, this particular storykeeper deals in some rather unusual merchandise: a missing woman whose skeleton may have turned up in a wooden box, a cow whose reputation ended up before the U.S. Supreme Court, a suffragist who entertained Susan B. Anthony, and a founding mother who apparently had little patience for troublesome husbands.

And Schmidt has plenty more where those came from.

The retired Elmhurst School librarian recently self-published “A Portrait of Portsmouth, Rhode Island: Stories and Images of Our Past and Present,” a coffee table-style paperback of more than 200 pages that takes readers on a neighborhood-by-neighborhood journey through the town’s colorful history.

Schmidt, who also maintains the popular Portsmouth History Notes blog, shared some of those stories during the well-attended presentation.

“Portsmouth has a unique history and it is just so much fun to research it,” she said.

Although Schmidt may resist the title of historian, she has arguably become the town’s unofficial keeper of its past, particularly since the death in February of longtime Town Historian Jim Garman, an author and lecturer whose work she greatly admired.

She learned from Garman and other local historians, including Edward West and John Pierce. But Schmidt has developed her own approach, one that places as much emphasis on the everyday people, oddball characters and forgotten women of Portsmouth as on its famous founders and Revolutionary War heroes.

And she believes those stories are worth preserving.

“I started gathering stories when I was a librarian at Elmhurst School. As a librarian I wanted to teach research skills,” said Schmidt, who retired in 2008.

She wanted children to learn how to examine old maps, dig through newspaper articles and, perhaps most importantly, speak with people who remembered the past.

“My golly, talk to a person and get information, because people are one of the best sources of information.”

One early project involved the Leonard Brown House, which Elmhurst parent Craig Clark was researching. Third-graders interviewed people who had grown up there. Hearing their firsthand accounts transformed the old building from an abstraction into something worth saving.

The cover of Gloria Schmidt’s new self-published book, “A Portrait of Portsmouth, Rhode Island: Stories and Images of Our Past and Present.” The paperback, which runs more than 200 pages, takes readers on a neighborhood-by-neighborhood journey through the town’s history, highlighting forgotten characters, unusual events and lesser-known stories.
The cover of Gloria Schmidt’s new self-published book, “A Portrait of Portsmouth, Rhode Island: Stories and Images of Our Past and Present.” The paperback, which runs more than 200 pages, takes readers on a neighborhood-by-neighborhood journey through the town’s history, highlighting forgotten characters, unusual events and lesser-known stories.
“Suddenly, it became very important to preserve it,” Schmidt said.

Students even illustrated the stories they collected, including scenes of the mill stream running through the Glen.

Schmidt still follows that philosophy. Research shouldn’t simply gather dust in a notebook.

“If I just keep it in my notebook, what good is it?”

A founding mother with attitude

Consider Herodias Long Hicks Gardiner Porter, whose name alone suggests a complicated life.

“The reason she had so many names is that she married three of the founding fathers,” Schmidt explained.

Herodias arrived in Portsmouth with her first husband, Hicks, and had three children. The marriage deteriorated, and she complained to the courts about his treatment of her. He eventually departed for Connecticut, taking her money.

She later entered a common-law relationship with Gardiner and had nine more children.

A Quaker, Herodias once walked 60 miles to Weymouth, Massachusetts, with a nursing baby and another child beside her to protest religious persecution. Authorities whipped her and imprisoned her for 14 days.

Her relationship with Gardiner also soured, with a judge eventually describing both parties as “scandalous.” She subsequently married Porter.

“That’s an interesting story to me because it’s not at all what I would expect from a founding mother,” Schmidt said.

Then there was Mary Paine Tripp, a barmaid at Balston’s Tavern in the Bristol Ferry neighborhood. According to Schmidt, a man once traded her a parcel of land for a pint of wine.

That land is now Mount Hope Park.

Not a bad return on a drink.

Murder, mystery and a celebrated cow

Some of Schmidt’s favorite discoveries sound less like local history than plots from mystery novels.

Gideon Manchester, for example, operated the drawbridge at Stone Bridge between Portsmouth and Tiverton. But his earlier life included a mystery that followed him long after his death.

His wife disappeared in the 1840s under suspicious circumstances. Manchester was accused in connection with her disappearance, but nothing came of the case.

In 1902, two boys discovered a wooden box along the Island Park shoreline. Inside were the skeletal remains of a woman.

Speculation immediately turned to Manchester’s missing wife. An old account even described a mysterious man carrying a large box across Stone Bridge around the time she vanished.

The remains were never conclusively identified, and the mystery remains unsolved.

Then there’s Missy of the Glen, a cow whose butterfat production became a matter of national legal importance.

Missy belonged to H.A.C. Taylor, who developed Glen Farm into one of the most technologically advanced agricultural operations of its time. The barns even featured a hot-water heating system to keep the animals comfortable.

Missy was said to produce milk with the highest butterfat content of any cow, a claim someone challenged.

Taylor sued, and the dispute eventually reached the U.S. Supreme Court.

“Missy’s the only cow that I know of that went to the Supreme Court,” Schmidt said.

Taylor won $10,000, although his grandson later maintained that he spent $25,000 on lawyers.

A victory, perhaps, but not necessarily one to milk for all it was worth.

Another grim story concerns the Slocum family, whose burial ground near Glen Farm sits alongside that of the Cundalls. Curiously, the Slocum gravestones face east while the Cundalls face west.

Schmidt recounted a tragedy involving two Slocum boys and an Indigenous servant. One boy was struck and fell overboard into the Sakonnet River; the other drowned.

Joseph Cundall, meanwhile, brought valuable knowledge of textile mills from England, where sharing such industrial secrets was prohibited. His own story ended mysteriously after a Christmas Eve delivery of wood. His body wasn’t discovered for four days.

Women who changed Portsmouth

Schmidt is particularly interested in women whose contributions have been overshadowed by more familiar historical figures.

Among them is Sarah Eddy, an artist, suffragist and philanthropist who lived in a large Victorian home on Bristol Ferry Road.

Eddy painted portraits, supported women’s rights and established a “social studio” to keep neighborhood children occupied and engaged.

“She figured if you kept kids busy, they’re not going to get into trouble,” Schmidt said.

Eddy was also remarkably generous.

“She never sold anything; she always gave everything away.”

Impressive circle of friends

Her circle included Susan B. Anthony, who visited Portsmouth and stayed in Eddy’s turret room. Eddy painted Anthony’s portrait to celebrate the suffragist’s 80th birthday, incorporating neighborhood children presenting her with a rose.

Julia Ward Howe, author of “The Battle Hymn of the Republic,” was another visitor to the area.

“Bristol Ferry was a hotbed of women’s rights,” Schmidt said.

Eddy also donated the art room at the Portsmouth library, leaving a legacy that extends well beyond her paintings.

Other stories highlight the town’s Black history, including formerly enslaved people brought to Portsmouth after the Civil War by a member of the Macomber family. Some eventually purchased their own farms and became successful agricultural producers. One supported the Portsmouth library from its earliest days.

For Schmidt, these are precisely the connections that make local history come alive.

“In Portsmouth I’m trying to get as many connections as we can,” she said.

Her book also explores the 1938 hurricane’s devastation at Common Fence Point, the murder trial of Rebecca Cornell, the curious history of Portsmouth’s flag, and Metcalf Bowler, a prominent colonial figure later revealed to have supplied information to the British.

It’s a reminder that history is rarely as tidy as the monuments and plaques might suggest.

2026 by East Bay Media Group

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.