PORTSMOUTH — The most telling moment in Monday night’s sign ordinance vote came not during deliberations, but during a tense exchange with the man who forced the town to rewrite the law in the …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
Register to post eventsIf you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here. Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content. |
Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.
PORTSMOUTH — The most telling moment in Monday night’s sign ordinance vote came not during deliberations, but during a tense exchange with the man who forced the town to rewrite the law in the first place.
“I’m also the person that this sign ordinance is directed at,” resident Michael DiPaola told the council remotely. “Whether you guys blatantly say it or not, that’s another story.”
What followed was a back-and-forth that quickly escalated.
As DiPaola began to broaden his remarks, council president Keith Hamilton cut in: “If you’re not going to talk specifically about the sign ordinance, you will be disconnected.”
“I’m going to try, and I have the right to talk,” DiPaola replied.
The owner of a lot at 1074 East Main Road that’s filled with signs directing his ire at town government, DiPaola said the town’s conduct “has moved beyond simple regulation into a coordinated, bad-faith crusade against my property and my constitutional rights. I am Sugar Ray Leonard, the counterpuncher in this battle, and not the aggressor, which is the bully — Portsmouth Town Hall.”
DiPaola charged that an unnamed council member started a petition to have his signs removed. “You cannot petition away the First Amendment,” he said.
Moments later, his microphone was silenced. “Mr. DiPaola, you have been cut off because you are not speaking to the sign ordinance,” Hamilton said. DiPaola was given another chance to speak, but he did not address the council again.
The exchange was brief, but it captured the underlying tension that has hovered over this issue for years — and the reason the council found itself voting, 4-3, to approve a rewritten ordinance after months of debate.
A law undone — and rebuilt
The town hasn’t been able to enforce its sign ordinance since 2021, when DiPaola — backed by the American Civil Liberties Union of Rhode Island — successfully challenged it in federal court.
At the heart of that case was a basic constitutional problem: the ordinance was not “content-neutral.” In practice, officials had to read a sign’s message to determine whether it violated the rules. A consent judgment barred the town from enforcing the ordinance, effectively tying its hands.
Since then, the town has been trying to write a new one — one that regulates signs based on size, placement, lighting and duration, not what they say.
Town Planner Lea Hitchen said that approach isn’t optional. “I think we could become legally vulnerable if we were to call out every type of sign,” she said. “We’re trying to stay content-neutral.”
The revised ordinance reflects that shift. It removes references to specific types of signs — political, real estate, yard sale — and instead sets uniform rules. Temporary signs can remain for up to 180 days; after that, they are considered permanent and must meet stricter standards. Signs are not allowed in public rights-of-way but are permitted on private property with permission.
On paper, it’s straightforward. In practice, council members made clear, it may not be. It even raised practical concerns among council members.
“Where am I going to put my political signs in the fall?” asked council vice president David Gleason.
He was told such signs would need to remain on private property — such as his yard in Common Fence Point — unless he obtained permission to place them on other privately owned parcels.
Not a ‘slam-dunk’
“Sometimes things of this nature have unintended consequences,” said Gleason. “I think the anticipation in town is this is a slam-dunk, and I don’t feel it is a slam-dunk.”
Hitchen agreed: “It definitely is not a slam-dunk.”
Much of the concern centered on enforcement — or the lack of it. “With just the five of us in the office, we’re not going to see every sign,” Hitchen said, noting that staff typically respond to complaints or address issues they encounter during routine work.
Education, she added, will likely matter as much as enforcement. “Those have always been the rules,” she said of signs placed on utility poles and in public areas. “But it’s difficult to enforce.”
Other council members said uncertainty is already widespread.
“I had a couple of residents tell me it was too restrictive to homeowners,” said council member David Reise. “It’s very confusing.”
“It’s going to be one heck of a thing to enforce,” added council member Mary McDowell.
Council member Sharlene Patton pointed to the reality on the ground — community events like the Rotary car show that rely on widespread signage.
“I think they’ve always been” placed throughout town, she said.
Hitchen’s response was consistent with the new legal framework: such signs are allowed — just not in the public right of way.
A vote, but not an ending
Despite the concerns, the council moved forward. Council member Juan Carlos Payero made the motion to approve the ordinance, which passed 4-3 over the objections of Gleason, Reise and Patton.
But even as the vote closed one chapter, it did little to settle the broader dispute that prompted it. The new ordinance restores the town’s ability to regulate signs — something it has lacked for years. What it does not guarantee is resolution, either with DiPaola or with residents frustrated by displays they find offensive.