The long and winding road to the bridge report

More than two years of communications from government officials reveal inconsistent direction and confusion over which federal agency had authority to permit the release of the Mt. Hope Bridge Inspection Report

By Christy Nadalin
Posted 11/19/26

Pull-out box: “We didn’t want to launch them [the bridge reports] into an unknown bureaucratic void. We wanted to launch them into a known bureaucratic void.” -Robert Metzler, Deputy Chief, SSI

…

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Register to post events


If you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here.

Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content.

Day pass subscribers

Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.


The long and winding road to the bridge report

More than two years of communications from government officials reveal inconsistent direction and confusion over which federal agency had authority to permit the release of the Mt. Hope Bridge Inspection Report

Posted

As the Rhode Island Turnpike and Bridge Authority (RITBA) took more than two years to release their Mt. Hope Bridge Inspection Report, citing Sensitive Security Information (SSI) and the need to get approval from the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), the agency was roundly criticized by residents and local governments, with the Town of Bristol filing a lawsuit in federal court on March 12 of this year, in an effort to compel the report’s release.

An Access to Public Records Act (APRA) request for communications between RITBA and the federal government pertaining to the bridge report delivered a trove of emails that suggest that RITBA’s attempts to gain authorization to release the report began as early as February of 2024, shortly after receiving an APRA request for “most recently completed inspection reports for the Sakonnet River Bridge, the Claiborne Pell Bridge, the Jamestown Verrazano Bridge, and the Mount Hope Bridge.” At that time, the most recent Mt Hope Bridge inspection report available dated to 2022.

In a Feb. 23, 2024 email to the SSI office of the TSA, Eric Seabury, RITBA’s engineering director, wrote: “These reports are subject to Title 49 CFR section 1520. Pursuant to the regulations and guidance on the TSA’s website, public record requests for this type of information are to be sent to TSA ‘for a full SSI Review and redaction prior to sharing with non-covered persons.’ Accordingly, please find in the linked OneDrive folder, the most recent inspection reports for only Mount Hope Bridge and Sakonnet River Bridge that are responsive to the requester’s APRA request and contain SSI…We appreciate TSA’s full review and analysis of all of the documents at this link in their entirety to determine whether any of them contain any non-SSI information that may be released.”

Title 49 CFR section 1520 is the federal regulation that governs protection of SSI.

On March 14, Seabury received a reply from Robert Metzler, Deputy Chief of the SSI Program confirming that the inspection reports should be protected, but he said that he was going to seek concurrence from the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and that RITBA should wait to hear further from the TSA and FHWA.

“Eric, just this afternoon I finally have concurrence from TSA internal SME (subject matter expert) that the information should be protected,” Metzler wrote. “He feels that before finalizing TSA should have concurrence from DOT/FHWA…I will be reaching out to FHWA hopefully today but more likely tomorrow. I am still waiting on the lawyers to determine whether Title 49 CFR 1520, which was created to protect security information, may be used to protect the safety/maintenance information.”

‘Things are moving slowly’
Metzler next reached out to Seabury on April 4, 2024, writing “Eric, things are moving slowly but they are moving. I am setting up a meeting between TSA and DOT to include SMEs attorneys and DOT’s SSI program to discuss the way forward. DOT is reaching out to ASHTO (American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials) to get a sense of stakeholder receptiveness to expanding the SSI regulation into this area. I suspect RITBA has obligations to respond to the records request in a timely manner, but unfortunately federal interests take precedent, so RITBA will not be able to produce any documents you reasonably believe may contain SSI until our SSI assessment process has been completed.”

No definitive answer
About another six weeks passed before Seabury again heard from Metzler, on May 17, 2024. Metzler said that he prodded FHWA asking if they had received feedback on the proposal to use SSI to protect bridge and tunnel inspection reports and was told that there was not a definitive answer but the the general consensus is that most states have some sort of INFOSEC (information security) policy in place that would limit access or distribution. Metzler’s source suggested proposing the question at the upcoming June meeting of AASHTO’s committee on transportation system security and resiliency.

Metzer suggested that bringing the matter before AASHTO would be helpful and that the SSIP (Sensitive Security Information Program) has completed its section level review and is prepared to identify the portions of the report it believes to be sensitive and requires some form of protection.

'What do we need to do?'
A few days later, on May 22, 2024, Metzler emailed Seabury to clarify that the authority of his office is in identifying SSI, and that the documents are not SSI based on a strict interpretation of the language of the regulation as they do not contain information obtained or developed in the conduct of security activities.

“The information was not developed in the conduct of safety activities through the SSI program, though the SSI program does recognize the utility of significant portions of the records to those who may seek to harm U.S. bridges and tunnels, and it’s prepared to share a recommendation to protect,” Metzler wrote. “I do not know how long the process of deciding whether TSA will or will not make a determination under 49 CFR 1520…in the event the administrator declines to expand the regulation to include these reports what option does Rhode Island have to protect the reports?”

“Rob, we have no direct way to protect these documents through Rhode Island laws and regulations,” replied Seabury. “That said, what would we need to do to have TSA make a determination under 49 CFR 1520 that the information should be protected, and if so, determine how would that work on our end?”

Reports a ‘great utility to any terrorist’
On February 20, 2025 Metzler emailed Seabury to say that though the inspection reports did not constitute
SSI under a strict interpretation of federal regulations, TSA was still determining if bridge inspection reports are subject to protection. RITBA to still wait to hear from TSA. Metzler noted that “…our subject matter experts concur that the reports would be a great utility to any terrorist or other malefactor planning an attack on transportation assets.”

Metzler also wrote that TSA recognizes that the nature of the documents involved DOT safety equities rather than TSA security equities and that determination should be drafted by DOT. “Complicating matters was the removal of independent authority for SSI by Congress, which was subsequently restored. TSA has been holding onto the records to provide DOT the opportunity to restore their SSI programs during this time.”

“Eric, my excuse for the delay, such as it is, is that we were waiting for DOT and its components to reestablish their own SSI programs so there would be someone for us to hand the materials for processing,” said Metzler in a follow up email the next day. “We didn’t want to launch them into an unknown bureaucratic void. We wanted to launch them into a known bureaucratic void.”

A new report is added to the queue
Seabury replied to Metzler, acknowledging that RITBA will continue to protect reports until advised otherwise by TSA.

On April 17, RITBA transmitted the 2024 MHB final inspection report to TSA for SSI determination.
“Rob, we recently completed a new 2024 Mount Hope Bridge inspection report,” wrote Seabury. “In the list currently under review by FHWA for SSI is the former 2022 Mount Hope Bridge inspection report. As you can imagine the material content is very similar, but simply with updates and perhaps new items can you please forward this to FHWA also for their SSI review.”

In July of 2025 RITBA received a voicemail from Jason Carnes, Transportation Security Coordinator at the FHWA: “I wanted to make sure we kind of went full circle on this because I think we just received a press inquiry from the individual that requested the FOIA to begin with,” he said. “The short of it is that we would agree with the SSI determination within the document itself and TSA's idea that it also would be SSI.”

On August 19, Seabury emailed Metzler to let him know that Carnes had called in July to let RITBA know they were going to be deeming the inspection reports in their entirety as SSI and that Seabury should expect a formal email saying so, but that he had not yet received that email.

A government shutdown and furlough impacting the employment of “non-essential” federal government employees began Oct. 1 and ended Nov. 12, 2025. On Nov. 20 TSA advised RITBA they were back from furlough and back to reviewing the issue.

Reed’s office steps in
Senator Jack Reed’s office attempted to get some answers, and in an April 30, 2026 email the TSA replied to Reed’s staff that while their subject matter experts and legal team agreed that the information in the report was worthy of protection, current SSI protections under Title 49 CFR section 1520 were not appropriate since the reports were developed in the conduct of safety activities, not security activities.

The emails reads in part: “In March 2024 the SSIP discussed with the DOT/FHWA Federal Highway administration whether the bridge reports should be determined to be SSI and suggested it would be more appropriate for DOT to make a determination considering the reports appear to focus on safety and not security. DOT recently had their SSI authority reinstated. TSA added that if the matter was related to security, TSA would make the SSI determination. DOT/FHWA concurred and informed TSA they would also consult with their stakeholder associations.”

Short story long and many acronyms later, it was stated that any SSI determination will be made by DOT and not TSA as the report was safety related.

“TSA did not make any final SSI determinations regarding the bridge maintenance reports as they are not within TSA regulatory activities. The determination was left for DOT/FHWA for consideration as it may be detrimental to transportation safety. We recommend engaging with DOT/FHWA,” the email concluded.

On May 1, 2026, Metzler emailed Seabury. “Eric I’m out of the office for a bit. Wanted to make sure you were not left out of the notification train. Acting administrator has determined to take no action. I do not know but fourth-hand observation is that decision is based at least in part on preference of POTUS to not expand federal regulation.”

SSI ‘inappropriate or inaccurate’
A new player, Christian Estevez, Chief of SSIP entered the fray on May 5.

“A decision was made that TSA would not proceed with a new determination for the inspection records for multiple bridges in Rhode Island to be categorized as Sensitive Security Information,” he emailed to RITBA. “The decision was made as a result of a determination that the inspection records were produced as a result of safety activities and not security activities. Any concerns that were identified in these reports were not considered to be detrimental to transportation, security, and the information should not receive SSI protections under the TSA SSI authority to prevent disclosures of such concerns.

"I would also advise you to remove the sensitive security information marking on the bottom of the documents as such markings could be deemed as inappropriate or inaccurate.”

A cautious confirmation
On May 7, Seabury emailed Estevez.

“We are writing to clarify the TSA’s change in position regarding the sensitive security nature of the report submitted for review. We wanted to check back with you because if the documents do not contain SSI under Rhode Island law, we must release them to the public. Due to the nature of the request and legal processes that are involved, that will happen imminently upon receiving a final answer.”

Seabury summarized the history of the communication on the issue and then concluded:
“Your office indicated that its last position on this matter was TSA did not make any final SSI determinations regarding the bridge maintenance reports as they are not within TSA regulatory activities. The determination was left for DOT/FHWA for consideration as it may be detrimental to transportation safety…we need to ensure that this is the final position on behalf of all impacted agencies prior to releasing the full unreacted documents to the public.

"If we are still awaiting input from DOT/FHWA please advise. If not, and this is final on behalf of all impacted agencies, will we receive formal written communication or should this email serve as that communication? Once we release these documents to the public it cannot be undone. Therefore, we are just seeking to confirm that we will not get conflicting guidance from one of the other agencies that have expressed concerns. We will be calling you shortly and ask that you take our call.”

After a conference call the day prior, RITBA Executive Director Lori Caron Silveira emailed all stakeholders on May 15, 2026 confirming that federal agencies would not be protecting the reports and that RITBA would respond to the APRA request accordingly.

“Since July 2025 we have been expecting an email confirming the bridge inspection reports contain SSI and cannot be released into the public domain," Caron Silveira wrote. "We now understand that SSI determinations for complex bridge inspection reports do not currently come within the purview of the TSA. They also currently do not fall within FHWA’s limited SSI regulatory authority…We now understand that any redaction of a complex bridge inspection report to protect information of a sensitive nature can (and should) be done at the level of the agency having responsibility for maintaining and protecting the critical structure. This would be consistent with the practices of other agencies throughout the country that maintain and protect similar complex bridge structures. We will respond accordingly to the public records requests we have received.”

Wait, what?
On May 20 TSA counsel emailed RITBA counsel, advising RITBA counsel that the report subject to the pending lawsuit should not be released until RITBA hears further from TSA.

On July 10 RITBA counsel emailed TSA counsel to confirm that TSA has determined that the report subject to the lawsuit does not contain or constitute SSI and may be released pursuant to APRA; TSA counsel confirmed. That day, RITBA released the unredacted Mt. Hope Bridge Inspection Report.

Town’s lawsuit remains open
Though the lawsuit filed against RITBA by the town of Bristol to force the release of the inspection report was dismissed as moot on August 11, the issue was left alive to respond to Bristol’s request for reimbursement of about $3,000 in legal fees. As of press time, the court has not ruled on that matter.

Mt. Hope Bridge, inspection, SSI

2026 by East Bay Media Group

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.