PORTSMOUTH — The town is challenging recent state affordable housing laws, saying the changes impact local zoning, land use and development review and may strain local resources.
The town …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
Register to post eventsIf you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here. Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content. |
Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.
PORTSMOUTH — The town is challenging recent state affordable housing laws, saying the changes impact local zoning, land use and development review and may strain local resources.
The town council voted 7-0 on Jan. 27 to approve both a formal resolution and a joint statement aimed at building cooperation among cities and towns across Rhode Island. It calls for municipalities to collaborate in analyzing and responding to more than 30 housing-related bills enacted by the Rhode Island General Assembly in recent years.
Council Vice President David Gleason, who brought the item forward, said other communities share Portsmouth’s concerns about how the laws are being applied.
He said many towns feel they have been put into a “one-size-fits-all predicament” by state land-use changes. He added that the resolution serves as a municipal statement to be shared with other communities in hopes they will support Portsmouth in “any potential actions or solutions.”
The resolution was drafted by Town Solicitor Giovanni Cicione, who said more than 30 bills could fall under low- and moderate-income housing modifications, but the resolution focuses on those most relevant to municipal authority.
According to Cicione, the measure directs the town to explore legal options in cooperation with other municipalities. Any future legal action would be up to the council.
Home rule powers cited
The resolution states that Portsmouth recognizes the statewide need for more affordable housing but also affirms municipal home rule authority over land use, zoning and comprehensive planning. It argues that uniform statewide standards may conflict with local comprehensive plans, infrastructure limits, environmental constraints and fiscal conditions.
It cites several recent laws affecting accessory dwelling units, redevelopment of abandoned properties, permitting procedures, wetlands regulation and limits on local zoning controls tied to affordable housing development.
“My main concern about all of this is the state potentially requesting us to drink from the fire house, and putting the pressure on staffs and our planning boards and zoning board to interpret this things on the fly,” said Council President Keith Hamilton.
Municipalities need additional time to understand and implement the requirements in a way that fits local plans, and the state must “stop forcing the implementation and allow us to really figure out how it fits into our own comprehensive community plan,” he said.
Hamilton also emphasized the resolution represents the council’s position and not that of town staff members who regularly work with state agencies and applicants.
Gleason has previously raised concerns about the state’s requirement that communities reach 10 percent low-to-moderate income, or LMI, housing. In a Jan. 6 email referenced in council discussion, he said the target is not attainable for Portsmouth under current counting rules.
“Whether I am right or wrong, we would need to see an additional 500-plus LMI units … built to achieve this goal and only if no other housing construction were to occur during that timeframe,” Gleason wrote.
Based on figures he shared, the town has been informed it currently stands at 2.66 percent LMI housing — 204 units out of 8,441 homes. He said the current formula does not count mobile homes or Section 8 units toward the total.
“There are 359 mobile homes that don’t count towards the 10 percent!” Gleason wrote. “Adding these properties would increase our number to 6.7 percent.”
Joint municipal statement
Along with the resolution, the council approved a joint municipal statement expressing shared concerns among Rhode Island communities. The statement supports expanding affordable housing but warns that a uniform statewide approach may produce unintended results because cities and towns differ in geography, infrastructure capacity, environmental constraints and existing housing stock.
The statement calls for collaboration among municipalities, shared legal and planning analysis, and coordinated efforts to seek clarification or judicial review where needed. It also urges state leaders and agencies to work with local governments to amend or interpret the laws with greater flexibility based on local conditions.
The town clerk is directed to send the approved resolution and joint statement to all Rhode Island municipalities, the governor and members of the General Assembly, as well as Portsmouth’s legislative delegation, requesting their support and potential legislative changes in the 2026 session.