PORTSMOUTH — After months of debate and three public meetings, the Planning Board on Thursday, Oct. 9, unanimously approved preliminary plans for an affordable housing development at the corner …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
Register to post eventsIf you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here. Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content. |
Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.
PORTSMOUTH — After months of debate and three public meetings, the Planning Board on Thursday, Oct. 9, unanimously approved preliminary plans for an affordable housing development at the corner of Bristol Ferry Road/Turnpike Avenue and Sprague Street, despite objections from several abutters.
The project is proposed by Church Community Housing Corporation (CCHC), which is also finishing up construction on a senior housing complex, along with a senior center, further north on Bristol Ferry.
The nonprofit’s latest plan calls for 40 residential units to be built on either side of Sprague Street on separate “north” and “south” lots. The north lot, where a one-story former day care center and school building is located, will contain two buildings: a townhouse-style structure with three, four-bedroom units, and a garden-style, 12-unit walk-up with a mix of one-, two-, and three bedrooms.
The vacant “south” lot, which was used as a gas station many years ago, will contain one elevated building with 25 residential units, featuring a similar mix of bedrooms. As an amenity, there will be a gym in a portion of the building to serve residents on both lots.
Of the proposed 40 units, 11 are targeting homebuyers, at 50 percent of the area median income (AMI) under the state’s comprehensive permit statute. Another 11 are targeting homebuyers at 80 percent of AMI, and the remaining 18 units are for those at 100 to 120 percent of AMI.
Board says law limits discretion
Both applications were approved unanimously, with Planning Board member Luke Harding recusing himself due to a conflict of interest.
Planning Board Chairman Ed Lopes noted the town has less than 3 percent of its housing stock classified as affordable, far below the 10-percent threshold required by state law.
“We’re 33 out of 39 cities and towns not meeting the quota,” Lopes said, adding the board had limited room to deny the proposal given the statute’s legal requirements.
Before the final vote, board member Ryan Tibbetts said he was sympathetic to abutters’ concerns, but emphasized the board’s duty to rule on the application before it. “Our charter is to the merits of this single petition,” he said. The board ultimately approved the plan subject to conditions related to fencing, downlighting, and coordination with neighbors on screening and design.
Traffic, utilities, parking
CCHC’s attorney, J. Russell Jackson, told the board the project met the town’s parking requirements. “We have a surplus of 13 spaces available to residents and guests of this project. We believe there’s ample parking for this project,” he said. While the south lot exceeded its minimum requirement, the north lot was four spaces short, but Jackson said residents could park across the street if needed.
Project engineer Mike Russell of LDEC Engineering said water service would be available to both sites through tie-ins on Bristol Ferry Road and Turnpike Avenue.
Traffic engineer Paul Bannon said the development’s impact on local roads would be minimal. “There hasn’t been any growth in the intersection for a decade-plus,” he said. Bannon added the state Department of Transportation (RIDOT) has already awarded a contract to upgrade the nearby Sprague Street and West Main Road intersection, including new sidewalks, wheelchair ramps, and resurfacing.
“There will be connectivity between the buildings on both sides of the road, because they share amenities,” Bannon said, noting crosswalks and ADA-compliant signals would be included.
CCHC Development Director Stephanie Booker cited enrollment data showing a steady decline of 43 public school students per year projected through 2035. “This will not create overcrowding or be a burden on the school system,” she said.
Neighbors push back
However, Nate Seelig of Sprague Court, who opposed the project, said that’s not what he’s heard, noting a school official recently told him that enrollment is actually increasing.
Seelig, who wrote a letter of objection to the planning board, said he wasn’t against affordable housing, just CCHC’s plan as presented.
“The size is just too much for the neighborhood,” he said.
Other residents who spoke during the two-hour public hearing urged the board to reject or scale down the proposal.
“I’m not quite sure where the town of Portsmouth is going these days,” said Kevin Fennessey of East Main Road. “This seems to me to be a rush to put a building on every square foot of the Town of Portsmouth.”
Several speakers said the development was too large for the neighborhood and would worsen traffic and safety problems on Sprague Street, where sidewalks are limited.
“This will be a major influx of vehicles onto an already stressed roadway network,” said Tom Grieb of Thayer Drive. “Isolated Planning Board decisions which consider only one project at a time could be a disaster.”
Others said the design did not provide enough parking. “You’re only going with one spot for a two-bedroom unit,” said Sprague Street resident Dave Schuller. “You need two spots … The designer is trying to hide the fact that he doesn’t have enough parking spaces.”
Several abutters also raised concerns about noise, lighting, and septic system capacity. “All the parking is going to be right next to me. You’re going to have overhead lights that are going to be going in my backyard,” said Carolyn Spaulding of Sprague Court.
Landscape architect Melissa Desjardins, speaking for CCHC, said the project would use fencing and evergreen buffers to protect abutting properties. “If abutters prefer fencing, we can do that,” she said, adding that lighting would be “full cut-off” and designed to stay within the parking lots.
Rosemary Gallagher, whose yard abuts the west side of the property, worried that the project’s septic system could fail. “It will back up in my yard, because it’s way too small,” she said. Lopes responded that all systems would require state Department of Environmental Management approval, and that “technology has improved,” which may explain why the designs appear smaller than expected.
One resident also charged the town didn’t provide adequate public notice regarding the application. “It seems this was fast-tracked,” said Turnpike Avenue resident Arthur Vouté. “The whole town should have been notified.”
Lopes pushed back, saying all abutters within 300 feet had been notified by mail and “there is a public notice that we follow for all of this.”
Affordable housing needs
Other speakers defended the project, however, saying Portsmouth’s shortage of affordable housing has made it nearly impossible for young people and seniors to stay in town.
Portsmouth Housing Authority Chair Jim Seveney said the development aligns with long-term goals to make the town more inclusive. “One of our longstanding goals has been to find a way to make this place affordable enough for our children to live here, and we have not achieved those goals,” he said. “All of our current affordable housing assets have waiting lists well in excess of 100 people.”
Seveney said the proposal “meets and exceeds” the town’s comprehensive plan goal of supporting affordable options “not just for our seniors, but for our children as well.”
State Rep. Michelle McGaw echoed those sentiments. “This is not happening at breakneck speed for people who need housing,” she said. “Families that grew up here can’t afford to stay in the place where they feel most comfortable and where their family and friends are. People are in desperate need of affordable housing.”
She added that many teachers, retirees, and working families want to remain in Portsmouth but are priced out of the current market. “We want our teachers to be able to stay here and we want our children to be able to live here,” she said.
Local residents also spoke in favor, including a teacher in her early 30s, Kate Boulay, who said, “Even with a stable teaching career, I can’t afford to buy a home in the town I love.” She called the project “an opportunity for people like me.”
Another resident of similar age, Jake McGaw of Camara Drive, said, “I would love to have a place of my own some day. Unfortunately, half of my friends are in the same boat. This is one of the most important political issues of the day.”
What’s next?
CCHC Executive Director Christian Belden said the organization will next apply for state housing funds. “If we got a funding award in May or June, then construction could start late next summer at best,” he said. “We would expect a 12-month construction period.”
The project still requires several state approvals before building permits can be issued.
While the Planning Board’s decision marked a key step forward, the split reaction underscored a community wrestling with growth, housing affordability, and development that doesn’t negatively impact neighbors.
As one resident, Annabel De Sousa of Sprague Street, put it, “Abutters are not opposed to that land being used for low-income housing. It’s the size of the project we have a problem with. Once it is put in place, it can’t be taken away.”
Editor’s note: Two of the residents quoted as speaking in favor of the proposal, Michelle McGaw and Jake McGaw, are the wife and son, respectively, of this story’s author.