Housing market leaves locals priced out of the American Dream

By Ethan Hartley
Posted 7/16/25

The unprecedented and brutal reality of the modern housing market has turned a young East Providence couple's modest wish into a waiting game.

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Register to post events


If you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here.

Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content.

Day pass subscribers

Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.


Housing market leaves locals priced out of the American Dream

Posted

By all measures of the past, Jimmy Dufurrena and his wife, East Providence native Melodie Pimentel, should have ticked off all the boxes to own their first home by now.

Each is 28 years old. They are both employed full-time within professional careers — Jimmy in surveying and Melodie a case worker for a behavioral healthcare facility. They don’t spend lavishly on themselves nor do they have expensive habits or hobbies.

And yet for the past four years, they’ve taken up residence at the Riverside home belonging to Melodie’s parents, who immigrated to America from their native homes in the Azores.

“We’ve been saving for several years. We have good credit. We’re doing alright in the grand scheme of things,” Dufurrena said in a recent interview. “We’re doing everything right. I don’t drink, smoke or do drugs, and I am very conservative with my savings … It’s a fine line where, with the savings I have after saving for years and years, we’re approaching the ability to do the bare minimum. The price of homes is outpacing the savings rate. It’s very troublesome.”

Such is the harsh reality for many young people in a situation similar to theirs.

It’s a situation where, in the span of five years, the median price for a home in Rhode Island exploded from around $250,000 in early 2020, to more than $500,000 for the first time in the state’s history in May of 2025.

What the current housing market looks like to a couple like Dufurrena and Pimentel is unrecognizable even to seasoned real estate veterans like Luis Mateus, who is the owner, broker and a practicing realtor at Mateus Realty, which has been operating in East Providence for 50 years.

“I mean, I've seen a lot of things go on,” said Mateus. “I always tell people I survived the Blizzard of ’78, I survived the banking crisis of ’91, and I survived COVID. Hopefully, I'll survive this as well, but as far as these prices jumping so rapidly and by the numbers they have, I have never experienced this before.”

According to Mateus and other housing sector experts, a combination of low housing stock, stagnant production of new units, and sky-high interest rates resulting in ballooning mortgage payments, has created a perfect storm for those looking to purchase their first home — a storm where even what used to be considered a modest “starter home” is simply unaffordable.

“I think to myself all the time,” Dufurrena continued. “If I made the wages I make now, but it was five years ago, whenever the market was less turbulent, I would have been all set.”

A supply problem
According to Mateus, supply of houses for sale has seen a significant uptick in East Providence since the winter months of 2025, but it remains very low compared to historical averages.

“In the early ’90s, when the banking crisis happened in Rhode Island, I alone had over 70 or 80 listings,” he said. “Right now, all the realtors put together in the city have about 38. Inventory is really low … Back in January and February of this year, the whole of East Providence probably had about eight or nine houses on the market.”

Basic economics dictates that low supply and high demand will result in steeper prices. So today, the home that was purchased for $250,000 in 2018 will likely go on the market for $400,000, or even as high as $500,000 if it’s in a desirable area. But Mateus did say that with stock rising in recent months, buyers have become more selective and aren’t rushing to overpay as quickly.

“So the competition kind of begins now where some buyers are willing to throw offers lower than the asking price, only because there's a little bit more to choose from,” he said. “But there are still some bidding wars going on.”

Mateus said another reason for low housing stock is the high interest rates, which means even if you can sell your home for a higher amount than you anticipated, your purchasing power from that sale goes way down; particularly if you want to move up to a more expensive home in Rhode Island or around New England.

“There's always, unfortunately, people passing away. There's always, unfortunately, people getting divorced. So, those people, most of them will have to sell in order to settle things up,” he said. “But those buyers that want a step up from where they started, they want to go into a bigger house, that part of the market has really slowed down. I would think that if the interest rates were lower you would see a lot more properties coming on the market because it would be a lot of peoplen who want to get into something bigger, or something smaller.”

And a production problem
The other large part of the problem is housing production. Rhode Island Speaker of the House, K. Joseph Shekarchi has been vocal about the problem for years, often repeating that Rhode Island has been repeatedly last or close to last in the number of new homes built in the entire country.

A series of legislative bills and packages of bills have been enacted in recent sessions to try to address the problem, including many bills aimed at making it easier for developers to earn approval to build in vacant buildings, for families to add accessory dwelling units to their properties, and most recently by creating a housing bank to assist in transitioning abandoned or delinquent properties into developable land.

The ultimate results of all of this (or lack thereof) will take years to determine.

One of the drivers of low production, according to Mateus (who also dabbles in flipping small developments), is the steep cost of acquiring property.

“If you're building a house, and you're buying a 5,000-square-foot lot in East Providence — where we used to buy it for $8,000, $12,000, $15,000, and we thought we were paying too much — now you’re paying $130,000, $135,000,” he said. “There isn’t that much new construction going on. And there's not very much land in the city of East Providence available anyways.”

It’s a problem that Carla DeStefano, executive director of the nonprofit affordable housing developer SWAP, Inc., is quite familiar with.

According to her, the elevated cost of land acquisition and construction, combined with aforementioned high interest rates, has created an untenable situation for developers, just as it has for buyers.

“Everybody thinks that developers make a ton of money. And in some cases you can make a lot of money. But you don’t make a lot of money around here,” she said. “Whether you are a nonprofit or a for-profit, we're all building with the same materials. We're all pretty much paying the same price for property.”

As an example, DeStefano said that building a starter home in Rhode Island right now — something around 1,200 square feet, with three bedrooms and one-and-a-half bathrooms — would cost as much as $475,000. In order to make a minimum profit worthy of making that investment, the house would need to be priced above $500,000 in order for the math to work.

But the target demographic for such a home, like first-time homebuyers,  are not players at those prices.

“Rhode Islanders — whether they're policemen, firemen, teachers, registered nurses — are they making that same percentage more than they did 10 years ago? Absolutely not,” she said. “Income has not kept up with the cost. So here we are.”

The problem of creating so-called “affordable housing” — where the annual cost of the housing doesn’t exceed 30% of a certain percentage of the area median income (AMI), usually 80-120% depending on the type of housing — gets even more complex, as developers make less money on affordable homes and affordable units while still experiencing similar costs to construct them.

SWAP, for example, recently constructed three townhomes in Rumford, each of which contain a rental unit that could supplement the buyer’s income to help pay the mortgage and were sold through a lottery to first-time homebuyers for the once-normal, now incredible cost of $250,000.

But the cost to build those homes? Around $700,000, according to DeStefano, which required vast amounts of state and federal subsidies to make it feasible for SWAP to take on the project.

“Are we going to be able to sell homes at $250,000 anytime soon without any subsidy put in it?” DeStefano asked. “No … No developer wants to go into a process that isn’t going to work.”

For Dufurrena and Pimentel, although their current living situation is stable and tolerable, they are understandably eager to strike out on their own and start their own journey in their own home in East Providence. But due to the current housing climate, they may have no other option but to just keep waiting, or look elsewhere.

“We want to own a home in the city my wife grew up in. I feel like the housing crisis is pushing people out of the towns they actually have a connection to,” Dufurrena said. “It’s not that [living with Melodie’s parents] is a bad situation. We get along with the family and all … but we want to start building equity. It’s more than just a living situation thing. It’s an economic mobility issue for people.”

Housing Rhode Island, Housing market RI, housing challenges Rhode Island, Housing market Rhode Island, buying a house in Rhode Island, East Providence Housing issues, East Providence Housing Market

2026 by East Bay Media Group

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.