As a current coach at Mt. Hope, I am familiar with the current policy. As it stands right now, any student that has a SINGLE failing grade is permitted to tryout for a team (or theatrical performance, etc...I believe it applies to ALL extra-curriculars), and they are allow to practice, rehearse, etc., but they are NOT permitted to participate in athletic contests (i.e. games, performances, etc.) Any student with two or more failing grades is not allowed to participate in extra-curricular activities...PERIOD. In my opinion, this is a fair policy, and the newly introduced (and later rescinded policy) was far too lenient, however, there is one major flaw (and this has happened...I've seen it):
What about the honors student who has maintained a 3.75 GPA, and chooses to challenge them self by taking an A.P. or honors class, and then they fail because the subject matter just simply isn't their "milieu?" They are not allowed to participate in extra-curricular activities. Meanwhile, a student who has received straight D's across the board in lower level classes is allowed to participate in all activities. In my opinion, this flaw in the policy is unfair to students who choose to challenge themselves, and actually discourages students from challenging themselves academically.
In my opinion, the policy should be based upon the overall GPA...not based upon single grades from a single quarter. I understand that this puts certain students at a disadvantage, as after a student's freshman year, it is difficult to improve a GPA dramatically. That being said, however, for those students whose GPA's suffer for external reasons (i.e. death in the family, illness, unforeseen circumstances, etc.), certain allowances can be made. The purpose of the policy is not to punish students who struggle, but rather encourage those who do not take their academics seriously to do so.
I hope that members of the school committee read this comment, and may perhaps even bring this suggestion to the SIT team, and also the administration.
GO HUSKIES!!!!
Please explain the inappropriate content below.
